Blog / Best Practices / Employee Experience & Wellbeing / Human Resources / Hybrid working / Performance Management

Effective Performance Review in a Hybrid Work Environment: Essential Practices

Performance Review

Creating a Positive and Stress-Free Experience for Both Managers and Employees with practical tips and phrases. Enhance performance review process in the new hybrid-work environment.

Performance Review

1. Preparation is Key

Proper preparation is essential for a successful performance review. As a manager, gather all necessary data and feedback before the review. This includes reviewing the employee’s achievements, challenges, and areas for improvement over the past year. Additionally, solicit feedback from colleagues and other managers to provide a well-rounded perspective.

Steps to Prepare:

  • Review Performance Data: Collect metrics, completed projects, and feedback from various sources.
  • Employee Self-Assessment: Encourage employees to complete a self-assessment to understand their perspective.
  • Peer Feedback: Gather feedback from colleagues who have worked closely with the employee.

2. Foster an Open Dialogue

Performance reviews should be an open conversation rather than a one-sided evaluation. Encouraging employees to share their thoughts, feelings, and suggestions fosters a sense of collaboration and trust. This approach shows that you value their input and are committed to their development.

3. Tips for Open Dialogue and Correct Body language in the Virtual setting:

virtual meeting
  • Active Listening: Pay attention and show empathy towards the employee’s viewpoints.
  • Encourage Questions: Make it clear that the employee can ask questions and seek clarifications.
  • Be Receptive: Be open to receiving feedback about your own management style.

In a virtual setting, body language plays a crucial role in conveying openness, attentiveness, and empathy. Here are some tips for managers to ensure their body language is effective during virtual performance reviews:

Maintain Eye Contact

  • Look at the Camera: When speaking, look directly at the camera to simulate eye contact. This makes the conversation feel more personal and engaging for the employee.
  • Avoid Distractions: Keep your focus on the screen to show that you are fully present and attentive.

Facial Expressions

  • Smile Naturally: A genuine smile can set a positive tone and make the employee feel more at ease.
  • Show Empathy: Use facial expressions to show understanding and empathy, especially when discussing sensitive topics.

Nod and Acknowledge

  • Nod Occasionally: Nodding indicates that you are listening and understanding what the employee is saying.
  • Verbal Acknowledgements: Use verbal cues like “I see,” “I understand,” or “That’s a good point” to reinforce your engagement.


  • Sit Up Straight: Good posture conveys professionalism and attentiveness. Avoid slouching or leaning back too much, which can appear disengaged.
  • Lean In Slightly: Leaning in a bit can indicate interest and involvement in the conversation.

Hand Gestures

  • Keep Hands Visible: If possible, position your camera to include some of your hand gestures. This adds a dynamic element to your communication and can make you seem more approachable.
  • Use Subtle Gestures: If your hands are not visible, you can still use subtle gestures like moving your head slightly to emphasise points.

Stay Calm and Composed

  • Avoid Fidgeting: Minimise movements that can be distracting, like fidgeting or adjusting your position frequently.
  • Maintain a Calm Demeanour: Keep a calm and composed demeanour, even when discussing challenging topics.

Lighting and Camera Angle

  • Ensure Good Lighting: Make sure your face is well-lit so that your expressions are clearly visible. Natural light or a soft lamp in front of you can help.
  • Position the Camera at Eye Level: This angle creates a more natural and engaging perspective, similar to an in-person conversation.

Practice Active Listening

  • Show Engagement: Use body language to show that you are actively listening, such as nodding, tilting your head slightly, and maintaining an interested expression.
  • Pause and Reflect: After the employee speaks, take a moment to reflect before responding. This shows that you are considering their words carefully.

By being mindful of these aspects of body language, managers can create a more positive and effective communication experience during virtual performance reviews. This helps in building trust, showing empathy, and ensuring that the conversation is productive and supportive.

relaxed conversation

4. Focus on Development and Growth

While addressing areas that need improvement is necessary, it’s equally important to highlight strengths and achievements. Framing discussions around how the employee can develop their skills and progress within the company can be highly motivating.

Development Focus:

  • Strengths and Achievements: Start with positive feedback to build confidence.
  • Constructive Feedback: Offer specific, actionable advice on how to improve.
  • Career Goals: Discuss long-term career aspirations and development opportunities.

5. Set Clear Goals and Expectations

Setting clear, SMART (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Time-bound) goals for the upcoming year provides direction and motivation for employees. Clear goals ensure that employees know what is expected of them and how they can achieve these expectations.

SMART chart

SMART Goals:

  • Specific: Clearly define what is expected.
  • Measurable: Establish criteria for measuring progress.
  • Achievable: Set realistic goals.
  • Relevant: Ensure goals align with broader company objectives.
  • Time-Bound: Set deadlines for achieving goals.

6. Follow Up Regularly

Annual reviews should not be the only time performance is discussed. Regular check-ins throughout the year can help track progress, provide ongoing feedback, and address any issues before they escalate.

Regular Check-Ins:

  • Monthly Meetings: Schedule brief monthly check-ins to discuss progress.
  • Quarterly Reviews: Conduct more in-depth reviews every quarter.
  • Continuous Feedback: Provide real-time feedback when necessary.

7. Enhancing the Experience for Both Parties

Creating a positive performance review experience requires attention to the needs of both managers and employees. Managers should approach reviews with empathy, understanding the potential stress and anxiety employees might feel. By fostering a supportive environment and emphasizing growth and development, managers can help alleviate these concerns.

Psychology Tips to Put Employees at Ease

  • Establish a Comfortable Setting: Hold the review in a comfortable, neutral location rather than a formal office. This can help reduce anxiety.
  • Start with Positives: Begin the review with positive feedback to set a constructive tone. This can help employees feel valued and appreciated.
  • Nonverbal Communication: Maintain open body language, such as uncrossed arms and leaning slightly forward. This can signal attentiveness and openness.
  • Practice Empathy: Show genuine concern for the employee’s feelings and experiences. Acknowledge their emotions and validate their efforts.

Example: Imagine you’re conducting a performance review with an employee named Alex. To put Alex at ease, you could start by saying, “Alex, before we dive into the specifics, I want to take a moment to recognise the fantastic work you’ve done on the recent project. Your dedication and creativity have been outstanding, and it hasn’t gone unnoticed.” This approach sets a positive tone, making Alex more receptive to constructive feedback that follows.

8. The Role of Technology in Performance Reviews

hybrid work

Leveraging technology can significantly enhance the performance review process. Tools like HybridHero offer continuous performance evaluation features that simplify and improve the review experience for both managers and employees. With real-time feedback and progress tracking, HybridHero eliminates the stress and anxiety often associated with traditional annual reviews.

Read more resources on conducting an effective performance appraisal.

9. How HybridHero Can Help

HybridHero provides a dynamic approach to performance management, ensuring that feedback is ongoing and constructive. This continuous evaluation process helps to build trust, eliminate surprises, and foster a culture of continuous improvement. By using HybridHero, managers can transform the annual performance review into a meaningful, stress-free experience that supports both employee development and organisational growth.

In summary, creating a positive performance review experience is crucial for fostering a motivated and engaged workforce. By preparing thoroughly, fostering open dialogue, focusing on development, setting clear goals, and leveraging technology, managers can ensure that performance reviews are beneficial for both themselves and their employees. HybridHero’s continuous performance evaluation tools further enhance this experience, making performance reviews a seamless and productive process.

Start creating better outcomes today

Get hybrid work right with HybridHero.

Book a Free Consultation